Enterprise software delivery is all about IT supporting business - not the other way around:
- Presidents, CEOs and founders drive the overall vision and strategy
- Product and Program Managers lead specific initiatives to support the vision and strategy
- Project Managers are responsible for the day-to-day operations within a project which includes managing Developers, Engineers, QA staff, Support, etc.
GitHub only aims to scratch the developer's itch, and even so it leaves a lot to be desired.
Have a look at this comparison to see why GForge is not just a replacement for Github - it's a huge improvement.
GitHub | |||
---|---|---|---|
Workflow |
YES | YES, BUT... | GitHub does have a feature that they call workflow. It does not provide the same automation features as GForge. |
Full Agile Support |
YES | NO | |
REST API |
YES | YES | |
Internal & External Collaboration |
YES | NO | |
Managed Hosting |
YES | NO | |
Cloud & Server-based Deployment |
YES | YES, BUT... | Requires GitHub Enterprise |
Offline Installation & Upgrades |
YES | YES, BUT... | Requires GitHub Enterprise |
Customized Tickets |
YES | NO | |
Pull Requests |
YES | YES | |
Document Management |
YES | NO | |
Chat |
YES | NO | |
Continuous Integration |
YES | NO | |
Knowledge Management |
YES | YES | |
Centralized Search |
YES | NO | |
Service Desk |
YES | NO | |
Single Sign-on (SSO) |
YES | YES, BUT... | Requires GitHub Enterprise |
Pricing Comparison: GForge vs GitHub
On the surface, GForge might appear to be a bit less expensive : GitHub (SaaS) is $9/user/month whereas GForge starts at $6.00/user/month. But when you add all of the 3rd party tools needed to match GForge features (like chat, kanban, document management and more), the overall pricing far exceeds what you'd pay for GForge.
For enterprise features, like on-premise installations or SSO login, GitHub Enterprise is even more expensive - ($20/user/month or more), and you'll still need all of those 3rd-party tools.
Outgrowing GitHub
As you consider a collaboration solution for Building Better Software, a feature comparison is only the beginning. Just because a feature is "there" doesn't mean it can meet your needs, or grow with your team. GForge CTO Michael Tutty took the time to write a 3-part series on "Signs You’ve Outgrown GitHub". Follow along as he expands on GitHub’s limitations around tags, task management and pull requests: